Top 10 Best Pizza Restaurants in Nashville

Five Points Pizza West brings the same beloved formula that made the East location a hit to the Nations neighborhood, delivering consistent New York-style pies to West Nashville's rapidly growing food scene. The Meatball pizza here is a protein-lover's dream—house-made meatballs, ricotta, marinara, and fresh basil piled onto a perfectly foldable slice. The neighborhood vibe is more laid-back than its East Side sibling, with plenty of families and regulars who appreciate quality pizza without the scene. Grab a whole pie, a local beer, and settle in for one of Nashville's most reliable pizza experiences.

Pelato in Germantown has mastered the art of Italian-American comfort with a modern Nashville twist, serving coal-fired pizzas alongside house-made pasta in a bright, airy space. Their Sausage & Peppers pizza features house-made fennel sausage, roasted peppers, and fresh mozzarella on a charred, smoky crust that borders on transcendent. The open kitchen lets you watch the magic happen, and the thoughtful wine list leans heavily Italian with plenty of by-the-glass options. It's equally suited for a casual weeknight dinner or a special occasion without the stuffiness.

Emmy Squared in The Gulch imports Detroit-style pizza mastery from its NYC roots, serving up thick, rectangular pies with caramelized cheese skirts that crackle like crème brûlée. The Emmy pizza—their signature topped with banana peppers, ranch, and red sauce cups—sounds chaotic but achieves perfect harmony between tangy, creamy, and spicy. The industrial-chic space fills up fast with Gulch professionals and couples who appreciate quality ingredients and a killer natural wine list. This is destination pizza worth planning your evening around.

The Hampton Social on 1st Avenue South has blown up as Nashville's rosé-all-day destination, but their pizza program quietly holds its own with upscale, shareable pies perfect for brunching groups. The Burrata & Prosciutto pizza—topped with creamy burrata, paper-thin prosciutto, arugula, and balsamic glaze—is Instagram gold and tastes even better than it photographs. The beachy, Hamptons-inspired decor and expansive patio make it a magnet for bachelorette parties and influencers, but the food legitimately delivers. Go for weekend brunch and stay for the people-watching.

Slim & Husky's in North Nashville is more than a pizzeria—it's a cultural movement celebrating Black entrepreneurship, hip-hop culture, and seriously good pizza in a neighborhood that deserves it. Their California Love pizza, topped with garlic butter, chicken, bacon, and ranch, sounds like drunk food but eats like art, with a perfectly chewy crust and generous toppings. The walls are covered in murals celebrating music legends, and the playlist bumps harder than most Broadway bars. Bring your crew, order a few pies, and soak in the community vibe that makes this place special.

Two Boots Nashville brings Louisiana-meets-NYC attitude to Broadway with funky, offbeat pizzas named after pop culture icons and loaded with Cajun-inspired toppings. The Cleopatra Jones—a spicy mix of shrimp, andouille, crawfish, and jalapeños—is their signature pie and a total flavor bomb that separates tourists from locals who know what's up. The vibe is loud, colorful, and unapologetically quirky, making it perfect for late-night cravings or budget-conscious groups who want character with their carbs. It's cheap, cheerful, and open late when everything else on Broadway is serving overpriced nachos.

The Stillery on 2nd Avenue is as much a craft cocktail destination as it is a pizza haven, offering elevated bar food in a stylish downtown setting with multiple floors and rooftop access. Their Detroit-style square pizzas are the sleeper hit—thick, airy dough with crispy, caramelized cheese edges that crunch with every bite. The Pepperoni Detroit-Style is a crowd-pleaser, but don't sleep on their seasonal cocktails that change monthly. Best for groups looking to make a night of it, especially before or after hitting Broadway's honky-tonks.

Tucked into Midtown's Villa Place, Bella Napoli Pizzeria brings authentic Italian soul to Nashville with wood-fired Neapolitan pizzas that transport you straight to the streets of Naples. The Margherita DOC here is textbook perfect—San Marzano tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, basil, and a blistered, leopard-spotted crust that's both pillowy and crisp. Owner and chef Giuseppe grew up in Italy, and it shows in every bite, from the house-made pasta to the tiramisu that'll ruin you for all other versions. This is where you take someone when you want to impress without the downtown tourist chaos.

Five Points Pizza East anchors the Woodland Street strip with New York-style pies that have locals lining up nightly for whole pies and by-the-slice options. This isn't your average pizza joint—the crust has that perfect foldable chew, and the White Pizza loaded with ricotta, garlic, and fresh basil is an absolute revelation. The bustling, casual atmosphere makes it ideal for families, groups catching up over pitchers of beer, or solo diners grabbing a quick slice at the bar. With nearly 5,000 glowing reviews, this is East Nashville pizza royalty.

Sho Pizza Bar has become East Nashville's worst-kept secret, slinging creative, upscale pies in a sleek, minimalist space that feels more Brooklyn than Broadway. Their Japanese-inspired approach to pizza means you'll find inventive toppings like miso honey and shishito peppers alongside impeccably charred crusts from their 900-degree oven. The Mushroom Truffle pizza is the move here—earthy, indulgent, and proof that Nashville pizza can compete with any coastal city. Perfect for date night or a low-key dinner with friends who appreciate craft over crowds.